If English academics can wax lyrical about a subject they have no clue of and confidently elucidate their opinions, why should Indian academics be left behind? Anil Maheshwari wrote a book on Alahazrat apparently, and as is the trend these days - one does not need to have knowledge in a subject to write a book.
Read More
An English academic talks about Alahazrat without any clue - but with the authority that only academics can in subjects they have no knowledge of, or expertise in. Much like Cyril Radcliffe decided the partition lines without any knowledge of India, its geograpy or its polity!
Read More
Mirza Engineer faults Alahazrat's translation of Surah al-Fat'h and accuses him of "doing an enormous injustice" even though, his ignorance is apparent to those who are familiar with commentaries. We will also see that Mirza's Arabic, (probably learned from Minhaju'l Arabiyyah) is not sufficient to make him a mufassir, much less a critic.
Read More